The "Shanghai Municipal Tax Service Measures for the Administration of Advance Tax Rulings (ATR) (for Trial Implementation)," effective as of December 29, 2023, represents a significant policy initiative by the Shanghai Municipal Tax Service, State Taxation Administration. This initiative is designed to standardize and improve the process of ATR in Shanghai, aligning with the broader goal of enhancing tax services and management for large enterprises. These measures are part of the effort to foster a stable, transparent, and business-friendly environment, showcasing the government's commitment to rule-based governance and responsive administration.

ATR is defined as a service offered by tax authorities based on mutual trust with enterprises. It provides guidance on applying tax laws and regulations to complex, future tax-related matters. This service is critical for enterprises seeking clarity on tax rule application, enabling them to make informed decisions while remaining tax compliant.

Corporate taxpayers in Shanghai are eligible to apply for ATR, which excludes matters lacking a definite plan, lacking a reasonable business purpose, clearly outlined in current tax laws, or other non-applicable matters. The application process involves submitting various documents, including an ATR Application Form, Acknowledgement Form, consents from competent authorities, and supporting materials. Accepted applications lead to the issuance of an ATR Opinion Letter, detailing related enterprises, tax matters, and legal basis. The ATR process can be terminated under specific circumstances, such as at the applicant's request, lack of necessary information, or other justifying reasons.

The implementation of ATR opinions is contingent on several conditions, such as the legality and accuracy of submitted documents and the consistency of actual tax matters with the application. These opinions apply only to the specific matters reviewed and do not extend to other taxpayers or unreviewed matters. Follow-up reviews are conducted by competent tax authorities, with the potential for termination or revocation of ATR opinions if substantial changes occur.

While ATR offers clarity and certainty, it does not constitute an administrative action impacting enterprise rights and obligations significantly. Therefore, administrative or court reviews are not available for ATR-related disputes, and taxpayers must seek legal remedies for specific administrative actions.

Despite its benefits, the ATR system faces challenges due to ambiguities and a lack of clear guidance from higher tax laws. There is uncertainty about the right to terminate the ATR process, especially when opinions seem unfavorable. Introducing a pre-communication procedure, akin to advance pricing arrangements (APAs), could provide taxpayers with preliminary opinions and the option to terminate the process. Additionally, taxpayers' statements during the ATR process should not adversely affect them in subsequent tax matters.

Another challenge is the mechanism for legal remedies. The Measures specify that ATR-related disputes cannot seek administrative or court review, potentially creating a conflict of interest if the reviewing authority for administrative review is also involved in the ATR process. This situation could undermine taxpayers' rights.

In summary, the Shanghai Municipal Tax Service's ATR Measures represent a milestone in tax administration, offering a means to achieve tax certainty. However, the potential conflicts and disputes arising from ambiguities and the absence of clear guidance from superior laws pose significant challenges. Taxpayers must engage in careful legal analysis to navigate these complexities and secure favorable ATR outcomes effectively.

At PHC Advisory, we can offer you full support on matters regarding doing business in Italy and Asia, or any other issues your business may face. If you would like to know more about policies relevant to your business in Italy or Asia, please contact us at info@phcadvisory.com.

About Us 

PHC Advisory is a company of DP Group: an international professional services conglomerate of companies with approximately 100 experienced professionals worldwide. We offer comprehensive services in tax, accounting, and financial consulting, including financial supervision, financial audit, internal audit, internal control over financial reporting, and support for audited financial statements and annual audits, ensuring clients' financial transparency and compliance.

Disclaimer

The content of this article is provided for informational purposes only, financial advice must be tailored to the specific circumstances on a case-by-case basis, and the contents of this article do not legally bind PHC Advisory with the reader in any way.

If you want to know more about doing business in China, please have a look at our previous articles:

• 2023 Tax Policy Review: Key Insights and Predictions for 2024

• Cross-Employment Issues in Chinese Affiliated Companies