In the dynamic and rapidly evolving landscape of cryptocurrency, India's stance on crypto taxation has attracted increased attention. The government's introduction of a controversial tax deducted at source (TDS) on all crypto transactions, along with a tax on crypto profits, has created debates and concerns within the increasing digital asset market. This article develops the complexities of the new taxation policy in India on crypto and the ongoing debates concerning its effectiveness and implications for the Indian crypto ecosystem.
The Genesis of the Controversy
In July 2022, the Indian government implemented a stringent taxation policy on cryptocurrency transactions which included a 30% tax rate on profits from crypto investments and a 1% TDS on all crypto transactions. The idea behind this policy was to increase traceability and curb speculative activities within India’s growing crypto market. However, this policy arouses strong pushback from the crypto community and industry experts.
Unintended Consequences and Market Response
The implementation of the 1% TDS and 30% tax on profits has had a notable impact on the Indian crypto market. A study by the Esya Centre, a New Delhi-based “think tank”, highlights several unintended consequences of this policy:
1. Shift to Offshore Exchanges: The study reveals that approximately 5 million Indian crypto traders have moved their transactions to offshore platforms, leading to a potential loss of $420 million in tax revenue for the Indian government.
2. Market Decline: Following the introduction of the tax, there was a significant decline in trading volumes on Indian crypto exchanges, with many struggling to stay afloat.
3. Failure to Curb Speculation: Contrary to the government's intentions, the tax policy has not effectively curbed speculative trading. Instead, it has pushed a substantial portion of the trade volume to less regulated, offshore platforms.
4. Lack of Transparency: One of the key targets of the new tax policy—increasing transparency in crypto transactions—has also not been achieved, as a large volume of trade has moved beyond the scope of Indian regulatory mechanisms.
The Call for Change
In light of these challenges, there has been a growing call to revise the crypto tax policy. The Esya Centre's report suggests lowering the TDS from 1% to 0.01% to encourage traders to return to domestic exchanges and enable the government to achieve its goals of revenue generation and improved transparency. This recommendation is supported by data indicating that a lower TDS rate could potentially generate over $1.5 billion in tax revenue over five years, while also ensuring better regulatory oversight.
Navigating Regulatory Complexities
The Indian government's approach to crypto taxation is part of a wider attempt to regulate a sector that has been historically difficult to govern. The Prevention of Anti-money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA), was extended to the crypto sector in March 2023, mandating due diligence and reporting of suspicious activities by crypto entities. This move signifies the government's recognition of the sector's growing importance and the need for effective regulation.
The Way Forward
As the debate continues, it becomes evident that finding a balance is essential for the growth of the crypto sector in India. The government's next steps will be crucial in determining the future trajectory of the Indian crypto market. It remains to be seen whether the authorities will consider the recommendations for tax policy adjustments or maintain the current regime.
In conclusion, the Indian tax system for crypto is complex and constantly changing, reflecting the broader global challenge of regulating digital assets. The outcome of this policy experiment will not only shape the future of India's crypto market but also offer valuable insights into the effectiveness of various regulatory approaches in governing the dynamic world of cryptocurrencies.
At PHC Advisory we stay updated on the relevant news on business matters in India. Feel free to follow us and get in contact at info@phcadvisory.com if you have any inquiries or if you need help with accounting and tax compliance services.
About Us
PHC Advisory is a company of DP Group: an international professional services conglomerate of companies with approximately 100 experienced professionals worldwide. We offer comprehensive services in tax, accounting, and financial consulting, including financial supervision, financial audit, internal audit, internal control over financial reporting, and support for audited financial statements and annual audits, ensuring clients' financial transparency and compliance.
Disclaimer
The content of this article is provided for informational purposes only, financial advice must be tailored to the specific circumstances on a case-by-case basis, and the contents of this article do not legally bind PHC Advisory with the reader in any way.
Related articles
If you want to know more about tax regulations in India, please have a look at our previous articles:
+86 21 6256 7995
info@phcadvisory.com
